SPIVA: It’s Not Another Artificial Sweetener

SPIVA - It’s Not Another Artificial Sweetener Mike Morton Financial Planning Podcast

“Nobody knows if a stock’s going up, down or [expletive] sideways, least of all stockbrokers! But we have to pretend we know.” – Matthew McConaughey in The Wolf of Wall Street

Actively managed funds versus low-cost index funds?, that is the question. How does one go about answering it? With research, of course. 

Talk to any broker, and they will tell you active management promises the potential for better returns through expert stock picking. Look at the data, and it is a different story altogether. Index funds have consistently outperformed actively managed funds over long periods. Let’s dive into the numbers and understand why this is the case.

SPIVA – It’s not another artificial sweetener

To make sense of the ongoing debate between active and passive investing, don’t just take my word for it. There’s research for that, a whole report in fact: SPIVA, which stands for S&P Indices Versus Active report. This research initiative, conducted by S&P Dow Jones Indices, compares the performance of actively managed mutual funds to their respective benchmarks. It provides a transparent, data-driven view of how well—or poorly—actively managed funds perform.

SPIVA reports take several important factors into account, making them one of the most trusted sources for this comparison:

  1. Net of Fees: The performance of actively managed funds is reported after fees, such as management and operating expenses. This is crucial because these fees often reduce the returns investors actually receive.
  2. Survivorship Bias: Many underperforming funds either merge with other funds or shut down entirely. SPIVA includes both existing funds and those that have been liquidated, giving a more accurate picture of overall performance.
  3. Impact of Closed Funds: Funds that no longer exist are often closed due to poor performance. Including them in the report means the data isn’t skewed by only looking at funds that survived, which typically perform better.

Key Findings from SPIVA Reports

One of the standout statistics from the SPIVA report is staggering: 87.42% of U.S. Large Cap funds underperformed the S&P 500 over the last 10 years. This means that almost nine out of 10 actively managed U.S. large-cap funds could not match the returns of a simple index tracking the S&P 500. 

The underperformance is not limited to U.S. large-cap funds. Across various asset classes—whether mid-cap, small-cap, international equities, or bonds—the trend is the same: most active funds fail to beat their benchmark over 1-year, 3-year, 5-year, and 10-year periods.

Even globally, the numbers are consistent. In regions like Europe, emerging markets, and Asia-Pacific, actively managed funds have a difficult time outperforming simple index funds.

Skewing the numbers: Fees

A major factor behind this underperformance is fees. Actively managed funds typically charge 0.5% to 1.5% in fees, while index funds often have expense ratios as low as 0.05% to 0.25%. 

Mike, 1.0% can’t make that big of a difference, can it?

Yes, it can. Over a 20-year period, a $10,000 investment growing at 7% annually would grow to approximately $38,000. However, if you’re paying 1% in fees and achieving a 6% return, your investment would only grow to around $32,000. That’s a $6,000 difference, so not only are you making less, but you are actively paying someone to do it for you.

Index Investing for the Win

So, what makes index funds more successful than their big-brained, savvy, human counterparts? 

Index investing involves buying into funds that track specific market indices, like the S&P 500. These funds hold all (or a representative sample) of the stocks in the index, making them naturally diversified and designed to match the market’s returns rather than outperform it.

Long Term Investing – Over the long haul, the majority of actively managed funds simply cannot keep pace with the market. Index funds are designed to capture the market’s performance as a whole and in doing so, eliminate the risk of trying to pick “winners” and underperforming as a result.

Market Efficiency – Another factor to consider is that today’s markets are highly efficient, making it extremely difficult for active managers to consistently exploit any new information before the rest of the market prices it in. As a result, beating the market consistently becomes more a matter of luck than skill.

Diversification – Index funds provide automatic diversification. Instead of betting on a handful of stocks, you’re investing in a broad swath of the market. Studies show that only 4% of stocks significantly outperform, so 96% either meet expectations or fall short. Index funds capture all winners and losers, spreading out the risk.

Consistency of Performance – Active funds may outperform for a year or two, but few maintain that winning streak over long periods. Index funds, in contrast, offer steady returns year after year without the same level of volatility and uncertainty.

Need more convincing? 

Index Funds Behavioral Advantages

Beyond the statistical and financial advantages, there are behavioral benefits to investing in index funds.

  1. Saves time: You don’t have to spend hours researching funds, managers, or specific stocks. Once you’ve chosen an index fund, you can set it and forget it.
  2. Peace of mind: By investing in an index fund, you know that you’re getting exposure to the entire market, reducing the anxiety of trying to beat the market and the stress that comes with watching individual stocks or active funds.

The data from SPIVA and countless other studies make one thing clear: index funds overwhelmingly outperform actively managed funds over the long term. The lower fees, broader diversification, and long-term market performance all add up to a powerful argument in favor of index investing. For most investors, index funds offer a straightforward, reliable way to grow wealth with fewer risks and less hassle than actively managed funds.

Are you ready to create your ideal lifestyle?  Let’s Connect.

Learn more about Mike and my services at https://www.mortonfinancialadvice.com and connect at https://www.linkedin.com/in/mwsmorton/

Investing: Active Vs. Passive

With the advent of the index fund in the 1970s, the battle began: actively managed funds versus passive index funds. Which belongs in your investment portfolio?

Actively managed funds have people responsible for deciding which companies to invest in and include in the fund. These funds will typically have a strategy to invest in a certain sector or style such as US large-cap growth companies or emerging market companies. 

Passive funds, on the other hand, use rules that define which companies to include in the fund. Examples include the S&P 500 (500 largest US companies) or the Russell 2000 Index (the smallest 2,000 companies in the Russell 3,000 index). These funds typically have very low ongoing expenses since no one is employed to actively research and make investment decisions.

This obviously begs the question: which is better for your investment dollars?  The research is in: the chances of you picking an active fund that outperforms a passive index is very small. In virtually every category of public investments, the index funds outperform a majority of the actively managed funds.

Investing in low-cost index funds has other benefits as well:

  1. You don’t waste time researching which manager to pick
  2. You don’t worry about a year of underperformance and if you should switch managers
  3. You can automatically add funds each month with no ongoing effort

It’s comforting to know that you will not only make more money over time but also spend less energy using passive index funds. Not often in life do we get such a win-win scenario.

Other topics discussed include:

  • Should you pay a wealth manager or financial advisor to “actively” manage your portfolio?
  • Are there scenarios where you recommend using actively managed funds?
  • Why do so many people still invest in actively managed funds?

Resources: