The Hidden Risk in Your Portfolio

The Hidden Risk in Your Portfolio - Morton Financial Podcast Mike Morton

When you think of powerhouse companies like Enron, Lehman Brothers, or even GE, a common thread emerges: they were once investor darlings—until they weren’t. If you had too much money tied up in them, the fallout was painful. That’s the heart of this week’s episode 

Why Single-Stock Risk is So Dangerous

It feels great when one stock is surging. Your net worth climbs, and you might even feel like a financial genius. But holding more than 10% of your portfolio in one company can expose you to what’s called concentration risk. And if you work for that company too? You’re doubling down. Your income and your investments are both tied to a single outcome.

Under the radar

Most people don’t intentionally bet big on a single stock. It often creeps in slowly in one or more of the following ways:

  • You work at the company and receive stock-based compensation (RSUs, options, bonuses)
  • You participate in Employee Stock Purchase Plans (ESPPs) and forget to sell
  • You let your winners ride, and suddenly, one holding dominates the portfolio
  • You feel emotionally attached, like selling would show disloyalty

Red Flag: More Than 10% in One Stock

If any single stock exceeds 10% of your total portfolio, it’s time to take a hard look. Even 5% might merit scrutiny. The market has proven time and again that even “safe” stocks can take sudden, permanent dives. According to J.P. Morgan, nearly 40% of Russell 3000 companies have seen permanent declines of 70% or more from their peak value. Only 4% of public companies outperform Treasury bills over time.

Translation: Stock picking is much riskier than most investors realize.

How to De-Risk, Minimizing Your Tax Burden

If you’re over-concentrated, don’t panic, but do plan.

  1. Create a step-down plan. Gradually reduce your position over 2–4 years to minimize capital gains taxes.
  2. Sell RSUs and ESPP shares right away. They’re a form of bonus pay—would you use a $30K cash bonus to buy more of your company’s stock?
  3. Donate appreciated shares. If you’re charitably inclined, contributing high-gain stock to a Donor-Advised Fund can earn you big tax breaks.
  4. Consider hedging strategies. For portfolios heavily dependent on one stock, advanced techniques like covered calls may offer downside protection, but tread carefully and get professional advice.

NUA: A Powerful but Tricky Tool

Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA) lets you move company stock from a 401(k) to a brokerage account and pay favorable capital gains tax on the growth, rather than higher ordinary income tax. But it’s complex and comes with strict rules. Don’t DIY this one.

Find out more about Mike at https://www.mortonfinancialadvice.com and connect at https://www.linkedin.com/in/mwsmorton/